3 answers
Britteny
Student
Spartanburg, South Carolina
12
Questions
Asked
1603 views
What are the pros and cons of being an instructional designer?
#instructionaldesign #education
Login to comment
3 answers
Andrew DeBell
Learning Content Developer at Atlassian
1
Answer
Ventura, California
Updated
Andrew’s Answer
Hi Britteny, great question. I've been creating instructional content for over 8+ years. Before you read my answers below, it's helpful to note that the 'pros and cons' of any career choice vary for each person. For example, I enjoy writing. So I'd put "writing" as a 'pro' of being an instructional designer (ID, for short). Other people may dislike writing and see that as a 'con' to the profession.
With that in mind, the below responses are what I see as pros and cons. You can use them to determine how they fit with your own personality and interests.
Pros (from my perspective):
- You get a learn about many different topics: This is a great profession for curious people. I've created learning content for university courses, company onboarding, insurance policies, software tools, supply chain processes, K-12 subjects like history and biology, retail POS systems, many more!
- You get to build a wide range of skills: The best IDs have skills in communication, writing, problem-solving, relationship-building, project management, visual design, research, multimedia, content development, and (sometimes) video production and graphic design.
- You can work from anywhere: Most modern ID work can be done remotely. As long as you have the skills to be able to effectively communicate with your team and SMEs (subject matter experts) through video meetings and email, you can complete your work from anywhere.
- You get to solve fun problems: ID work is all about solving problems. Often there is some type of knowledge or skill "gap" you're trying to solve. These problems can be fun to work on if you enjoy brainstorming and complex problem-solving.
- You get to write a lot: IDs need to be highly skilled at communicating through written word. Most of the work you'll do requires a significant amount of writing. You may need to write video scripts, content outlines, articles, instructional blogs, many other forms of writing.
- You get to work with a lot of different people: IDs spend a lot of time working with subject matter experts (SMEs, for short). These SMEs are the 'expert' on the topic you're creating instructional content for. You'll work closely with them to extract information and transform it into digestible content others can learn from.
Cons (from my perspective):
- It can be difficult to measure outcomes: One of the big problems for IDs is measuring their work. How can you tell if the course you built is actually helping solve a problem? Most often, your course will be attempting to alter human behavior. Behaviors can be especially challenging to measure on a large scale, making it difficult to measure your overall outcomes and show your value.
- Employment opportunities are more limited than other fields: Instructional design positions in the corporate world are often limited to Learning & Development teams (in Human Resources) or Customer Education teams in Sales. Those teams are often fairly small and only available in mid to large-sized companies. In fields like Sales or Marketing, there is a much larger pool of potential job opportunities. Companies of all industries and sizes need employees to help them sell and market their products. Just something to consider when deciding a career.
---
I hope these thoughts help! I've found instructional design to be an incredibly rewarding career choice. If you're at all interested, I'd encourage you to take some online courses to learn the basics. You can also try to create your own online course just for fun. This will help you understand the overall process of instructional design and see what parts you like and dislike. Best wishes to you!
Take online courses on Udemy or LinkedIn Learning
Create your own online course to see what you like/dislike about the process
Keep asking questions and learning from other professionals!
With that in mind, the below responses are what I see as pros and cons. You can use them to determine how they fit with your own personality and interests.
Pros (from my perspective):
- You get a learn about many different topics: This is a great profession for curious people. I've created learning content for university courses, company onboarding, insurance policies, software tools, supply chain processes, K-12 subjects like history and biology, retail POS systems, many more!
- You get to build a wide range of skills: The best IDs have skills in communication, writing, problem-solving, relationship-building, project management, visual design, research, multimedia, content development, and (sometimes) video production and graphic design.
- You can work from anywhere: Most modern ID work can be done remotely. As long as you have the skills to be able to effectively communicate with your team and SMEs (subject matter experts) through video meetings and email, you can complete your work from anywhere.
- You get to solve fun problems: ID work is all about solving problems. Often there is some type of knowledge or skill "gap" you're trying to solve. These problems can be fun to work on if you enjoy brainstorming and complex problem-solving.
- You get to write a lot: IDs need to be highly skilled at communicating through written word. Most of the work you'll do requires a significant amount of writing. You may need to write video scripts, content outlines, articles, instructional blogs, many other forms of writing.
- You get to work with a lot of different people: IDs spend a lot of time working with subject matter experts (SMEs, for short). These SMEs are the 'expert' on the topic you're creating instructional content for. You'll work closely with them to extract information and transform it into digestible content others can learn from.
Cons (from my perspective):
- It can be difficult to measure outcomes: One of the big problems for IDs is measuring their work. How can you tell if the course you built is actually helping solve a problem? Most often, your course will be attempting to alter human behavior. Behaviors can be especially challenging to measure on a large scale, making it difficult to measure your overall outcomes and show your value.
- Employment opportunities are more limited than other fields: Instructional design positions in the corporate world are often limited to Learning & Development teams (in Human Resources) or Customer Education teams in Sales. Those teams are often fairly small and only available in mid to large-sized companies. In fields like Sales or Marketing, there is a much larger pool of potential job opportunities. Companies of all industries and sizes need employees to help them sell and market their products. Just something to consider when deciding a career.
---
I hope these thoughts help! I've found instructional design to be an incredibly rewarding career choice. If you're at all interested, I'd encourage you to take some online courses to learn the basics. You can also try to create your own online course just for fun. This will help you understand the overall process of instructional design and see what parts you like and dislike. Best wishes to you!
Andrew recommends the following next steps:
Thanks for the information! I'm a teacher that is considering a career change.
Britteny
TLAUREN TLAUREN
CA
120
Answers
San Gabriel, California
Updated
TLAUREN’s Answer
A huge advantage of an instructional design is that it gives you the structure to find more with regards to who your students are and the way in which they learn. It additionally assists you with distinguishing the information and abilities understudies need to show before the finish of the arrangement or program: the learning objectives or results
David Benz
Instructional Designer/Trainer
1
Answer
Cincinnati, Ohio
Updated
David’s Answer
Hi Britteny- I've always enjoyed teaching and instructional design has been a way for me to expand teaching to a larger audience. For example, the online courses that I've built are able to be seen by thousands instead of a single class.
I would echo Andrew's response above on ...
1. You can do this work from anywhere. I've worked from a home office since 2006.
2. You get to meet a lot of great subject matter experts and learn a lot about different topics.
3. You get to develop a lot of different skills such as visual communication, multimedia, video production, elearning development, writing/scripting, and understanding learning gaps.
As far as cons, my biggest wish is that instructional design roles in non-profits and education would pay as well as instructional design jobs in the corporate world.
If this is something that interests you, you may also want to consider an area of subject matter expertise. For example, I have a software engineering background and this has allowed me to develop all kinds of training in the technical world because I'm fluent in the language and it's easy for me to speak to subject matter experts.
Hope this helps!
I would echo Andrew's response above on ...
1. You can do this work from anywhere. I've worked from a home office since 2006.
2. You get to meet a lot of great subject matter experts and learn a lot about different topics.
3. You get to develop a lot of different skills such as visual communication, multimedia, video production, elearning development, writing/scripting, and understanding learning gaps.
As far as cons, my biggest wish is that instructional design roles in non-profits and education would pay as well as instructional design jobs in the corporate world.
If this is something that interests you, you may also want to consider an area of subject matter expertise. For example, I have a software engineering background and this has allowed me to develop all kinds of training in the technical world because I'm fluent in the language and it's easy for me to speak to subject matter experts.
Hope this helps!