6 answers
Ali
Student
Elk Grove, California
1
Question
Asked
808 views
Why become a doctor v.s. a nurse or even a physician assistant?
Any tips, advice, or guidance would be extremely helpful. It would also be nice to hear anyone's own experience on why they made their decision.
6 answers
MARY OLAFUSI
Nursing
24
Answers
Ife, Osun, Nigeria
Updated
MARY’s Answer
The choice between becoming a doctor, a nurse, or a physician assistant depends on individual preferences, career goals, and personal strengths. Here are some key points to consider for each profession:
Becoming a Doctor:
1. Extensive Education: Doctors typically undergo more years of education, including medical school and residency, to become fully licensed physicians.
2. Autonomy: Doctors often have more independence and authority in decision-making regarding patient care and treatment plans.
3. Specialization: Doctors can choose from various medical specialties to focus on specific areas of medicine.
4. Leadership Opportunities: Doctors can lead medical teams and be involved in research and academia.
Becoming a Nurse:
1. Education Options: Nurses can pursue various education paths, such as associate degrees, bachelor's degrees, or master's degrees, allowing for flexibility in career advancement.
2. Patient Care: Nurses are hands-on caregivers, providing direct patient care and assisting with various medical procedures.
3. Diverse Settings: Nurses work in various settings, from hospitals and clinics to schools, community centers, and home healthcare.
4. Collaborative Role: Nurses often work closely with doctors, therapists, and other healthcare professionals to provide comprehensive patient care.
Becoming a Physician Assistant (PA):
1. Education: PAs typically complete a master's degree program, which is shorter than medical school, making it a quicker path to practice medicine.
2. Collaboration: PAs work under the supervision of doctors but have a degree of autonomy in patient care, diagnosing, and prescribing medications.
3. Specialization: PAs can choose specialized areas of practice and have the flexibility to switch specialties if desired.
4. Work-Life Balance: PAs often experience a better work-life balance compared to doctors due to fewer years of education and training.
Ultimately, the decision depends on your interests, career aspirations, and willingness to invest time and effort in education and training. Each profession offers unique opportunities to contribute to the healthcare field and make a positive impact on patients' lives. It's essential to research each role, gain relevant experiences, and consider your personal goals before making a choice.
Becoming a Doctor:
1. Extensive Education: Doctors typically undergo more years of education, including medical school and residency, to become fully licensed physicians.
2. Autonomy: Doctors often have more independence and authority in decision-making regarding patient care and treatment plans.
3. Specialization: Doctors can choose from various medical specialties to focus on specific areas of medicine.
4. Leadership Opportunities: Doctors can lead medical teams and be involved in research and academia.
Becoming a Nurse:
1. Education Options: Nurses can pursue various education paths, such as associate degrees, bachelor's degrees, or master's degrees, allowing for flexibility in career advancement.
2. Patient Care: Nurses are hands-on caregivers, providing direct patient care and assisting with various medical procedures.
3. Diverse Settings: Nurses work in various settings, from hospitals and clinics to schools, community centers, and home healthcare.
4. Collaborative Role: Nurses often work closely with doctors, therapists, and other healthcare professionals to provide comprehensive patient care.
Becoming a Physician Assistant (PA):
1. Education: PAs typically complete a master's degree program, which is shorter than medical school, making it a quicker path to practice medicine.
2. Collaboration: PAs work under the supervision of doctors but have a degree of autonomy in patient care, diagnosing, and prescribing medications.
3. Specialization: PAs can choose specialized areas of practice and have the flexibility to switch specialties if desired.
4. Work-Life Balance: PAs often experience a better work-life balance compared to doctors due to fewer years of education and training.
Ultimately, the decision depends on your interests, career aspirations, and willingness to invest time and effort in education and training. Each profession offers unique opportunities to contribute to the healthcare field and make a positive impact on patients' lives. It's essential to research each role, gain relevant experiences, and consider your personal goals before making a choice.
Hi Mary, thank you for taking the time to write such a detailed response! I will take this advice into consideration for the future!
Ali
This is a great response but I would also like to add that the role of a nurse practitioner is also an option. In many states such as Alaska, nurse practitioner are able to practice independently so I am not required to have a collaborating physician. I see patients in a clinic, obtain histories and do physical exams, order tests, interpret lab results, perform procedures, and order medications.
Marybeth Patterson
Autumn DeGroat, B.S., M.S., PA-C
Certified Physician Assistant
1
Answer
Saginaw, Michigan
Updated
Autumn’s Answer
I am a PA. My choice was because as a PA you get to work in whatever specialty you like and can switch back and forth to try different opportunities. As a physician, you go to residency for a specific thing and then practice that or go on to a fellowship to practice that. PAs have the ability to jump from one specialty to another because they are trained and do clinicals in multiple things. I like that it is 7-8 years of school total rather than 10-15 for MDs/DOs. Really it is about preference.
Hi Autumn, thank you for your response! I appreciate the additional info that compares the amount of schooling between the careers. I will make sure to consider that. :)
Ali
John Levesque
Clinical Quality Nurse
84
Answers
Waterville, Maine
Updated
John’s Answer
Mary's feedback is outstanding, and I'd like to build upon it by saying that some career paths can open doors to different roles in the future. I've had the privilege of working with paramedics who later chose to transition into roles as RN's, PA's, and even doctors. Additionally, I've witnessed numerous RN's who decided to further their education to become nurse anesthetists and nurse practitioners. Your unique journey might begin in one field and lead you to another. Remember, careers are a marathon, not a sprint, and it's perfectly okay if your goals evolve over time. You're not required to make a decision now that will determine your role for the rest of your life. The medical field is constantly advancing, and so are the professionals who dedicate their lives to it. So, embrace the journey and the opportunities it brings.
Hi John, it was really nice to hear about your experiences and I greatly appreciate the life advice!
Ali
jami adam
rph
22
Answers
Jupiter, Florida
Updated
jami’s Answer
The difference is the level of responsibility. The nurses do more hands on with patients. Pa's work under a provider, and physicians have their own practice.
Hi Evanne, I appreciate the input. Thank you for responding!
Ali
Madison Buchman
doctor
112
Answers
West Hartford
Updated
Madison’s Answer
Three awesome careers but you want to consider a few things. The differences in time to get your degree, cost of each degree, and then what your role in patient care will look like after you get that degree as well as differences in work/life balance. For some the shorter time period to become a PA vs a doctor is appealing and also costs less, however, in the end you may make slightly less and have different restrictions in care you can provide.
James Constantine Frangos
Consultant Dietitian & Software Developer since 1972 => Nutrition Education => Health & Longevity => Self-Actualization.
6342
Answers
Gold Coast, Queensland, Australia
Updated
James Constantine’s Answer
Hello Ali,
Why Become a Doctor vs. a Nurse or Physician Assistant?
Choosing a career in the healthcare field is a significant decision that requires careful consideration of various factors. When deciding between becoming a doctor, nurse, or physician assistant, individuals must weigh the differences in responsibilities, education requirements, scope of practice, autonomy, and career advancement opportunities.
1. Becoming a Doctor:
Responsibilities: Doctors are responsible for diagnosing and treating illnesses, injuries, and medical conditions. They have the authority to prescribe medications, perform surgeries, and make critical decisions regarding patient care.
Education: Becoming a doctor typically requires completing a bachelor’s degree, followed by medical school and residency training. This extensive educational path can take around 11-15 years to complete.
Scope of Practice: Doctors have a broad scope of practice and can specialize in various fields such as cardiology, neurology, surgery, etc. They often lead healthcare teams and have the final say in patient care decisions.
Autonomy: Physicians generally have a higher level of autonomy in clinical decision-making compared to nurses or physician assistants.
Career Advancement: Doctors have opportunities for career advancement through specialization, research, teaching positions, and leadership roles within healthcare organizations.
2. Becoming a Nurse:
Responsibilities: Nurses provide direct patient care, administer medications, assist with treatments and procedures, educate patients on health management, and collaborate with other healthcare professionals.
Education: To become a registered nurse (RN), individuals can pursue an associate’s degree in nursing (ADN) or a bachelor of science in nursing (BSN). Advanced practice nurses like nurse practitioners require additional education.
Scope of Practice: Nurses work under the supervision of doctors but play a crucial role in patient care delivery. They can specialize in areas like pediatrics, oncology, critical care, etc.
Autonomy: While nurses follow treatment plans established by doctors, they still have autonomy in providing direct patient care and making certain clinical decisions within their scope of practice.
Career Advancement: Nurses can advance their careers by pursuing advanced degrees (e.g., Master of Science in Nursing), specializing in specific areas of healthcare, or taking on leadership roles.
3. Becoming a Physician Assistant:
Responsibilities: Physician assistants (PAs) work under the supervision of doctors to provide diagnostic, therapeutic, and preventive healthcare services. They can conduct physical exams, order tests, interpret results, and assist in surgeries.
Education: PAs must complete a master’s degree from an accredited PA program after obtaining a bachelor’s degree. The educational path typically takes around 6-7 years to become certified.
Scope of Practice: PAs work closely with physicians but have some autonomy in patient care delivery. They can specialize in areas like primary care, emergency medicine, surgery, etc.
Autonomy: While PAs collaborate with physicians on patient cases and treatment plans, they also have some independence in managing patient care under physician supervision.
Career Advancement: PAs can advance their careers by specializing in specific medical fields through additional training or pursuing leadership roles within healthcare settings.
In conclusion,
Becoming a doctor, nurse or physician assistant is influenced by individual preferences regarding the level of responsibility desired, educational commitment, scope of practice, autonomy, and career advancement opportunities available within each profession.
Each profession offers unique rewards and challenges, and individuals should carefully consider their personal strengths, interests, and long-term career goals when choosing their path in the healthcare field.
Top 3 Authoritative Sources Used:
American Medical Association (AMA): The AMA is a leading professional organization for physicians that provides resources on medical education pathways, licensure requirements, specialty information, and career development opportunities for aspiring doctors.
American Nurses Association (ANA): The ANA is a prominent organization representing registered nurses nationwide, offering insights into nursing education programs, certification options, scope of practice guidelines, and career advancement resources for individuals considering nursing as a profession.
American Academy of Physician Assistants (AAPA): The AAPA is the national professional society for physician assistants, providing information on PA education programs, certification processes, specialty areas within the PA profession, and professional development opportunities for those interested in becoming PAs.
These sources were instrumental in providing accurate and up-to-date information on the roles, responsibilities, education requirements, scope of practice limitations and career prospects associated with becoming a doctor vs. nurse vs. physician assistant.
God Bless,
JC.
Why Become a Doctor vs. a Nurse or Physician Assistant?
Choosing a career in the healthcare field is a significant decision that requires careful consideration of various factors. When deciding between becoming a doctor, nurse, or physician assistant, individuals must weigh the differences in responsibilities, education requirements, scope of practice, autonomy, and career advancement opportunities.
1. Becoming a Doctor:
Responsibilities: Doctors are responsible for diagnosing and treating illnesses, injuries, and medical conditions. They have the authority to prescribe medications, perform surgeries, and make critical decisions regarding patient care.
Education: Becoming a doctor typically requires completing a bachelor’s degree, followed by medical school and residency training. This extensive educational path can take around 11-15 years to complete.
Scope of Practice: Doctors have a broad scope of practice and can specialize in various fields such as cardiology, neurology, surgery, etc. They often lead healthcare teams and have the final say in patient care decisions.
Autonomy: Physicians generally have a higher level of autonomy in clinical decision-making compared to nurses or physician assistants.
Career Advancement: Doctors have opportunities for career advancement through specialization, research, teaching positions, and leadership roles within healthcare organizations.
2. Becoming a Nurse:
Responsibilities: Nurses provide direct patient care, administer medications, assist with treatments and procedures, educate patients on health management, and collaborate with other healthcare professionals.
Education: To become a registered nurse (RN), individuals can pursue an associate’s degree in nursing (ADN) or a bachelor of science in nursing (BSN). Advanced practice nurses like nurse practitioners require additional education.
Scope of Practice: Nurses work under the supervision of doctors but play a crucial role in patient care delivery. They can specialize in areas like pediatrics, oncology, critical care, etc.
Autonomy: While nurses follow treatment plans established by doctors, they still have autonomy in providing direct patient care and making certain clinical decisions within their scope of practice.
Career Advancement: Nurses can advance their careers by pursuing advanced degrees (e.g., Master of Science in Nursing), specializing in specific areas of healthcare, or taking on leadership roles.
3. Becoming a Physician Assistant:
Responsibilities: Physician assistants (PAs) work under the supervision of doctors to provide diagnostic, therapeutic, and preventive healthcare services. They can conduct physical exams, order tests, interpret results, and assist in surgeries.
Education: PAs must complete a master’s degree from an accredited PA program after obtaining a bachelor’s degree. The educational path typically takes around 6-7 years to become certified.
Scope of Practice: PAs work closely with physicians but have some autonomy in patient care delivery. They can specialize in areas like primary care, emergency medicine, surgery, etc.
Autonomy: While PAs collaborate with physicians on patient cases and treatment plans, they also have some independence in managing patient care under physician supervision.
Career Advancement: PAs can advance their careers by specializing in specific medical fields through additional training or pursuing leadership roles within healthcare settings.
In conclusion,
Becoming a doctor, nurse or physician assistant is influenced by individual preferences regarding the level of responsibility desired, educational commitment, scope of practice, autonomy, and career advancement opportunities available within each profession.
Each profession offers unique rewards and challenges, and individuals should carefully consider their personal strengths, interests, and long-term career goals when choosing their path in the healthcare field.
Top 3 Authoritative Sources Used:
American Medical Association (AMA): The AMA is a leading professional organization for physicians that provides resources on medical education pathways, licensure requirements, specialty information, and career development opportunities for aspiring doctors.
American Nurses Association (ANA): The ANA is a prominent organization representing registered nurses nationwide, offering insights into nursing education programs, certification options, scope of practice guidelines, and career advancement resources for individuals considering nursing as a profession.
American Academy of Physician Assistants (AAPA): The AAPA is the national professional society for physician assistants, providing information on PA education programs, certification processes, specialty areas within the PA profession, and professional development opportunities for those interested in becoming PAs.
These sources were instrumental in providing accurate and up-to-date information on the roles, responsibilities, education requirements, scope of practice limitations and career prospects associated with becoming a doctor vs. nurse vs. physician assistant.
God Bless,
JC.
Delete Comment
Flag Comment