9 answers
5
Questions
Asked
687 views
Where can I find feedback on my poetry and other forms of creative writing?
I would like to get feedback on my writing in order to improve it. Especially for when I want submit pieces to literary magazines. I want to know if there are online communities I should join or websites I should look into. Ideally I would like to get feedback for free, but maybe could work out a small budget.
Login to comment
9 answers
Updated
Tiffany’s Answer
Try All Poetry (www.allpoetry.com). They give feedback, and you can give feedback, too. In order to write, you have to give feedback to at least two people (an option on the site). Pretty much any creative writing website, like Writer's Digest has forums, so depending on your literary magazine, you might be able to use their forum. I don't know the Writer's Digest website as much as All Poetry, but that's why I mention it: you can find a forum practically anywhere. Don't forget to try your local school. They have classes online, and continuing ed might have free classes.
Thank you so much for your advice and the resources!
Maya
Thank you!
Sara
Hi Tiffany! It is great that you want to give feedback and you are welcome to give any personalized feedback on CareerVillage. As a reminder, CareerVillage guidelines don't allow direct contact between professionals and students off platform.
Sharyn Grose, Admin
Updated
Michelle’s Answer
Maya, I am glad you reached out with this question because I am happy to say that there is a way for you to obtain feedback for your writing and it is indeed free. It is a Website called Writing and I have left the link for you below.
What makes this website special is that it has a large community of writers and you will have a Portfolio on your account at which you can store your writings. There are many posts that prompt creativity and themes for writing. You will even have the chance to give feedback to other writers as well. Try the Writing website for a while and if it turns out to not be what you'd like, do a search online for similar websites.
Best wishes in all you do !
WRITING WEBSITE - WHERE THE WRITERS GO https://www.writing.com/main/newsfeed
What makes this website special is that it has a large community of writers and you will have a Portfolio on your account at which you can store your writings. There are many posts that prompt creativity and themes for writing. You will even have the chance to give feedback to other writers as well. Try the Writing website for a while and if it turns out to not be what you'd like, do a search online for similar websites.
Best wishes in all you do !
Michelle recommends the following next steps:
Thank you so much! I've made an account :)
Maya
I'm excited to put your great advice to good use!
Sara
You are very welcome, Maya !
Michelle M.
Updated
Sophia’s Answer
Sometimes, at local libraries, they have writing groups for free! I'd either check out if possible their online calendar or call the front desk regarding their schedule of activities; though this may not be online, however I think it can still be something to still pursue, and the librarians (if you give them a call directly) may have ideas as well for something that is online.
Thank you so much. I didn’t know libraries did that!
Maya
Updated
Tami’s Answer
There's a wealth of social media groups dedicated to this sort of thing. While the feedback might not always match your expectations, it will certainly help you gauge how your work is likely to be received. Consider exploring local libraries, cafes, and bookshops that host "beat" or "open mic" nights.
However, bear in mind that the audience at these events might differ from an online or academic crowd. Your target audience and the message you wish to convey will largely dictate your approach. For instance, if you're marketing a poetry chapbook, it could be worthwhile to look into college bookstores, or even gift shops at museums and hospitals.
Poetry for children is a whole other story. Same goes for spiritual context. You'll have to do some real soul searching. What you find online is likely not enough and paying someone even a small amount will limit you to their sole opinions. A trusted teacher, professor, or even friends and family may be better than any or all other options. Thematic apperception is unique to everyone.
Create a sample that's not exhaustive but represents key elements of your work.
Describe the work in an illustrative way and make it publishable even if only a post card or other memory.
Consider creating a mood board and focus on repeating or centralized themes.
Improve the greater aspects of your work to really identify with a specific audience.
Have fun. Don't just throw yourself out there unless you're open to improv and slams.
However, bear in mind that the audience at these events might differ from an online or academic crowd. Your target audience and the message you wish to convey will largely dictate your approach. For instance, if you're marketing a poetry chapbook, it could be worthwhile to look into college bookstores, or even gift shops at museums and hospitals.
Poetry for children is a whole other story. Same goes for spiritual context. You'll have to do some real soul searching. What you find online is likely not enough and paying someone even a small amount will limit you to their sole opinions. A trusted teacher, professor, or even friends and family may be better than any or all other options. Thematic apperception is unique to everyone.
Tami recommends the following next steps:
Thanks, can't wait to put this advice into action!
Maya
Updated
Syeda’s Answer
There are several online communities and websites where you can get feedback on your poetry and creative writing:
Online Writing Communities:
Scribophile: A large community of writers where you can get feedback on your writing. The basic membership is free, and a premium membership is available for more features.
Wattpad: A platform where writers share their stories and get feedback from readers. It has a strong community and various writing contests.
Critique Circle: An online writing workshop where members exchange critiques. The basic membership is free.
Reddit: Subreddits like r/poetry, r/ocpoetry, and r/writing offer communities where you can share your work and receive feedback.
Writing Websites:
PoetrySoup: A free poetry community where poets can share their work and get feedback.
AllPoetry: The world's largest poetry community, where you can share poems, receive feedback, and participate in contests.
Workshops and Courses:
Coursera and edX: Offer free and paid courses on creative writing, where peer feedback is often a part of the learning process.
FutureLearn: Offers various writing courses, some of which include peer reviews and feedback.
Social Media:
Twitter: Follow and participate in writing communities and hashtags like poetrycommunity and writerscommunity.
Instagram: Engage with other writers and poets through hashtags like poetrycommunity and writingcommunity.
Writing Groups:
Meetup: Look for local writing groups or online writing groups that meet regularly to exchange feedback.
Facebook Groups: Join groups dedicated to poetry and creative writing where members share and critique each other's work.
If you have a small budget, you might also consider:
Reedsy: A marketplace connecting writers with professional editors for paid feedback.
Writer's Digest University: Offers workshops and webinars with professional feedback options.
Joining these communities and using these resources can provide valuable feedback to help you improve your writing.
Online Writing Communities:
Scribophile: A large community of writers where you can get feedback on your writing. The basic membership is free, and a premium membership is available for more features.
Wattpad: A platform where writers share their stories and get feedback from readers. It has a strong community and various writing contests.
Critique Circle: An online writing workshop where members exchange critiques. The basic membership is free.
Reddit: Subreddits like r/poetry, r/ocpoetry, and r/writing offer communities where you can share your work and receive feedback.
Writing Websites:
PoetrySoup: A free poetry community where poets can share their work and get feedback.
AllPoetry: The world's largest poetry community, where you can share poems, receive feedback, and participate in contests.
Workshops and Courses:
Coursera and edX: Offer free and paid courses on creative writing, where peer feedback is often a part of the learning process.
FutureLearn: Offers various writing courses, some of which include peer reviews and feedback.
Social Media:
Twitter: Follow and participate in writing communities and hashtags like poetrycommunity and writerscommunity.
Instagram: Engage with other writers and poets through hashtags like poetrycommunity and writingcommunity.
Writing Groups:
Meetup: Look for local writing groups or online writing groups that meet regularly to exchange feedback.
Facebook Groups: Join groups dedicated to poetry and creative writing where members share and critique each other's work.
If you have a small budget, you might also consider:
Reedsy: A marketplace connecting writers with professional editors for paid feedback.
Writer's Digest University: Offers workshops and webinars with professional feedback options.
Joining these communities and using these resources can provide valuable feedback to help you improve your writing.
Thank you!!! These are a lot of wonderful resources!
Maya
Updated
Betsy’s Answer
Hello! It's truly admirable that you're open to receiving feedback and eager to enhance your writing skills. In my own journey, I discovered affordable courses in my local area and at a community college that provided valuable advice and constructive feedback from fellow students. You might also consider reaching out to the editor(s) of your favorite poetry magazine for their recommendations - it's something I wish I had done! This approach not only broadens your connections but also allows you to establish a rapport with the editors.
The Writer's Market, a comprehensive guide, offers insights into what different publications are seeking in submissions. Aim to submit your work to those that resonate with your style of poetry. Remember, frequent submissions, rejections, and resubmissions are all part of the artistic process.
Another suggestion is to join writers' meetups via the Meetup app. These gatherings can be a treasure trove of learning and feedback. Make an effort to attend public readings at libraries and bookstores (yes, physical bookstores still exist!) and engage with fellow attendees.
However, be mindful when joining writing groups. If you find the feedback to be consistently negative and critical, it may not be beneficial. Constructive feedback should celebrate the positives and gently highlight areas for improvement. Writing groups should aim to uplift, not tear down. After all, improvement comes from a place of encouragement, not from a place of hurt.
The Writer's Market, a comprehensive guide, offers insights into what different publications are seeking in submissions. Aim to submit your work to those that resonate with your style of poetry. Remember, frequent submissions, rejections, and resubmissions are all part of the artistic process.
Another suggestion is to join writers' meetups via the Meetup app. These gatherings can be a treasure trove of learning and feedback. Make an effort to attend public readings at libraries and bookstores (yes, physical bookstores still exist!) and engage with fellow attendees.
However, be mindful when joining writing groups. If you find the feedback to be consistently negative and critical, it may not be beneficial. Constructive feedback should celebrate the positives and gently highlight areas for improvement. Writing groups should aim to uplift, not tear down. After all, improvement comes from a place of encouragement, not from a place of hurt.
Thank you, this is amazing! I really needed it.
Maya
Updated
Veronica’s Answer
You can discover folks on social media and various freelance platforms. While some may ask for a fee, others might offer their services for free.
I appreciate this, thank you for the advice.
Maya
Updated
Zoya’s Answer
Great question! Seeking feedback is essential for growth as a writer. Here are several avenues to explore:
Free Online Communities
Writing Forums and Communities:
Reddit: Subreddits like r/writing, r/poetry, and genre-specific ones.
Critique Circles: Many online communities offer peer review options.
Writer's Digest: Offers forums and contests.
Social Media:
Join writing groups on platforms like Facebook.
Share your work on Twitter and Instagram with relevant hashtags.
Paid Feedback Options
Professional Editors and Critique Partners:
Consider hiring a professional editor for in-depth feedback.
Find critique partners who offer paid services.
Writing Workshops and Conferences:
Attend workshops or conferences to connect with other writers and receive feedback.
Tips for Getting Effective Feedback
Be Specific: Clearly state what kind of feedback you're seeking.
Be Open-Minded: Be receptive to different perspectives.
Return the Favor: Offer feedback to others when possible.
Build Relationships: Foster connections with other writers.
Free Online Communities
Writing Forums and Communities:
Reddit: Subreddits like r/writing, r/poetry, and genre-specific ones.
Critique Circles: Many online communities offer peer review options.
Writer's Digest: Offers forums and contests.
Social Media:
Join writing groups on platforms like Facebook.
Share your work on Twitter and Instagram with relevant hashtags.
Paid Feedback Options
Professional Editors and Critique Partners:
Consider hiring a professional editor for in-depth feedback.
Find critique partners who offer paid services.
Writing Workshops and Conferences:
Attend workshops or conferences to connect with other writers and receive feedback.
Tips for Getting Effective Feedback
Be Specific: Clearly state what kind of feedback you're seeking.
Be Open-Minded: Be receptive to different perspectives.
Return the Favor: Offer feedback to others when possible.
Build Relationships: Foster connections with other writers.
I'm excited to put your great advice to good use!
Maya
Updated
WAYNE’s Answer
Proud of you for trying to get yourself out there Maya. Find some Facebook groups that specifically critique (so many exist). There are many with writers like yourself doing just that! This can also lead to even more focused communities like Discord groups for writers. Make sure to locate communities with active participants (those that post daily) so you're not having out in dead groups. Keep pushing and pumping that art out! Posting to social media can also be a great way to test natural feedback. Create short works that you can commit to posting on a regular schedule and monitor the response. I did this a few years ago and it helped boost my confidence (and I got better)!
I've linked a few groups below 👇🏾
https://www.facebook.com/groups/1976793849262471/?ref=share&mibextid=NSMWBT
https://www.facebook.com/groups/cathrineagnessimonepresentswritershelpingwriters/?ref=share&mibextid=NSMWBT
https://www.facebook.com/groups/2166222440346729/?ref=share&mibextid=NSMWBT
I've linked a few groups below 👇🏾
WAYNE recommends the following next steps:
Thank you!
Maya