4 answers
1
Question
Asked
439 views
Is CMA better than CNA and why?
Is it possible to be an ultrasound tech for this
Login to comment
4 answers
Updated
Doc’s Answer
Certified Nursing Assistants (CNAs) and Certified Medical Assistants (CMAs) are both healthcare professionals with different roles, training requirements, and career paths Jordan.
• CNAs — Focus on direct patient care in skilled nursing facilities, working closely with registered nurses (RNs) or licensed practical nurses (LPNs) to help patients with daily tasks. CNAs may assist with activities of daily living, take vital signs, provide basic wound care, and report concerns to nurses. CNAs may also need a strong work ethic and a passion for caring for others.
• CMAs — Handle a broader range of administrative and clinical tasks in outpatient settings, such as physicians' offices, hospitals, and clinics. CMAs may work directly under physicians to administer blood tests or perform electrocardiograms, or they may perform administrative tasks like scheduling appointments and recording patient histories. CMAs may also need additional skills or training, such as vaccine administration, dressing changes, or lab sample collection, depending on the setting.
CMA & CNA EDUCATIONAL REQUIREMENTS
• CNA — In order to become a CNA, you’ll need to have your high school diploma or GED. Then, you’ll need to complete nursing assistant training. These programs usually only last a few months and take place at community colleges, technical schools, and some medical facilities. After you’ve completed your education, you’ll take a certification examination. This test consists of written questions and a skills test where you demonstrate you know how to correctly perform several clinical skills. Once you’re certified, you’ll immediately be able to apply to CNA jobs.
• CMA — You can only earn a CMA certification if you are already a certified nursing assistant. In some states, you may have to work as a CNA for a period of time before you can get your CMA. You don’t need a college degree to become a CMA. Instead, CMA programs can be taken community colleges or trade schools. They usually take around four months to complete. After you’ve completed your training, you’ll need to pass an examination to get your certification. You’ll also need to continue your education — a medication aide certificate isn’t permanent, and you’ll need to renew it at certain intervals. Learn more about how to earn a medication aide certification in your state.
Jordan to become an ultrasound technician. There are four essential steps to follow. Most students need anywhere from 1-6 years to complete their ultrasound technician education, depending on their level of education before beginning the process and how extensive an educational pathway they choose. For example Jordan if you have earned your CMA certificate, a one-year certificate programs in sonography are available.
• STEP 1 — HIGH SCHOOL DIPLOMA
Earning a high school diploma or GED certificate is an important step toward gainful employment in almost any field. A high school education is your gateway to college and creating a career, and you absolutely need one in order to become an ultrasound technician.
• STEP 2 — SONOGRAPHY DEGREE
You may consider pursuing an associate degree in diagnostic medical sonography, which can take two years to complete. This option is ideal if you want to enter the field quickly without having to complete a four-year degree program. Some employers may require you to possess a bachelor's degree, so it's important to consider this when choosing your educational path. If you decide to pursue a four-year bachelor's degree program, ensure the program you enroll in meets the requirements of the Commission on Accreditation of Allied Health Education Programs (CAAHEP). Typically, coursework in a bachelor's degree program in diagnostic medical sonography covers topics in health science, mathematics and medical technology and provides practical experience. Bachelor's degree programs are more intensive than associate degree courses.
• STEP 3 — CLINICAL EXPERIENCE
You can gain clinical and practical experience by working with patients, such as through an internship. Clinical experience enables you to develop your interpersonal, communication, medical and technical skills. Your ability to interact with and build rapport with patients is an important skill that may be beneficial to you in a sonography role.
• STEP 4 — OBTAIN YOUR CERTIFICATE
Most employers require sonographers to possess certification in diagnostic medical sonography. Many sonographers obtain their Registered Diagnostic Medical Sonographer (RDMS) credential before specializing in an additional field of sonography. The American Registry of Radiologic Technologists (ARRT) offers several certifications besides the RDMS credential for sonographers in a specialty, including the Registered Diagnostic Cardiac Sonographer (RDCS), Registered Vascular Technologist (RVT) and Registered in Musculoskeletal (RMSK) certifications. All credentials require you to take and pass a certification exam prior to obtaining certification.
• CNAs — Focus on direct patient care in skilled nursing facilities, working closely with registered nurses (RNs) or licensed practical nurses (LPNs) to help patients with daily tasks. CNAs may assist with activities of daily living, take vital signs, provide basic wound care, and report concerns to nurses. CNAs may also need a strong work ethic and a passion for caring for others.
• CMAs — Handle a broader range of administrative and clinical tasks in outpatient settings, such as physicians' offices, hospitals, and clinics. CMAs may work directly under physicians to administer blood tests or perform electrocardiograms, or they may perform administrative tasks like scheduling appointments and recording patient histories. CMAs may also need additional skills or training, such as vaccine administration, dressing changes, or lab sample collection, depending on the setting.
CMA & CNA EDUCATIONAL REQUIREMENTS
• CNA — In order to become a CNA, you’ll need to have your high school diploma or GED. Then, you’ll need to complete nursing assistant training. These programs usually only last a few months and take place at community colleges, technical schools, and some medical facilities. After you’ve completed your education, you’ll take a certification examination. This test consists of written questions and a skills test where you demonstrate you know how to correctly perform several clinical skills. Once you’re certified, you’ll immediately be able to apply to CNA jobs.
• CMA — You can only earn a CMA certification if you are already a certified nursing assistant. In some states, you may have to work as a CNA for a period of time before you can get your CMA. You don’t need a college degree to become a CMA. Instead, CMA programs can be taken community colleges or trade schools. They usually take around four months to complete. After you’ve completed your training, you’ll need to pass an examination to get your certification. You’ll also need to continue your education — a medication aide certificate isn’t permanent, and you’ll need to renew it at certain intervals. Learn more about how to earn a medication aide certification in your state.
Jordan to become an ultrasound technician. There are four essential steps to follow. Most students need anywhere from 1-6 years to complete their ultrasound technician education, depending on their level of education before beginning the process and how extensive an educational pathway they choose. For example Jordan if you have earned your CMA certificate, a one-year certificate programs in sonography are available.
• STEP 1 — HIGH SCHOOL DIPLOMA
Earning a high school diploma or GED certificate is an important step toward gainful employment in almost any field. A high school education is your gateway to college and creating a career, and you absolutely need one in order to become an ultrasound technician.
• STEP 2 — SONOGRAPHY DEGREE
You may consider pursuing an associate degree in diagnostic medical sonography, which can take two years to complete. This option is ideal if you want to enter the field quickly without having to complete a four-year degree program. Some employers may require you to possess a bachelor's degree, so it's important to consider this when choosing your educational path. If you decide to pursue a four-year bachelor's degree program, ensure the program you enroll in meets the requirements of the Commission on Accreditation of Allied Health Education Programs (CAAHEP). Typically, coursework in a bachelor's degree program in diagnostic medical sonography covers topics in health science, mathematics and medical technology and provides practical experience. Bachelor's degree programs are more intensive than associate degree courses.
• STEP 3 — CLINICAL EXPERIENCE
You can gain clinical and practical experience by working with patients, such as through an internship. Clinical experience enables you to develop your interpersonal, communication, medical and technical skills. Your ability to interact with and build rapport with patients is an important skill that may be beneficial to you in a sonography role.
• STEP 4 — OBTAIN YOUR CERTIFICATE
Most employers require sonographers to possess certification in diagnostic medical sonography. Many sonographers obtain their Registered Diagnostic Medical Sonographer (RDMS) credential before specializing in an additional field of sonography. The American Registry of Radiologic Technologists (ARRT) offers several certifications besides the RDMS credential for sonographers in a specialty, including the Registered Diagnostic Cardiac Sonographer (RDCS), Registered Vascular Technologist (RVT) and Registered in Musculoskeletal (RMSK) certifications. All credentials require you to take and pass a certification exam prior to obtaining certification.
Updated
Michelle’s Answer
Hello, Jordan !
You ask an interesting question but far be it from me to say which career is better than any other career. No, you cannot be an Ultrasound Technician if you are a Certified Medical Assistant or a Certified Nurse's Aid. Those are two very different careers and you would have to take a specialized path to become an Ultrasound Technician.
If you want to determine which you'd like better, CMA or CNA, you'll need to explore both careers and pick the one that suits you best and the one that you like. If you have these fields of work explained to you, it may make it easier for you to make a personal choice about it.
Let's start with the career as a Nurse's Aid. I will base my information on personal extensive observation of many nurse's aids in action. I do not live in your state, so keep in mind that the guidelines, job duties and protocol for this position varies from state to state and depends on where exactly you will work. You most likely would work in a Hospital or a Nursing Home and Rehabilitation Center. That being said, the work is quite hectic. You would be doing direct patient care which includes bathing, dressing, grooming, transferring and repositioning of a patient, feeding and recording vital signs. You will need a neutral or high tolerance to bodily fluids because you will assist with changing and cleaning incontinence patients. There are a lot of job duties, so I continue. You would be responsible for reporting and recording (through charting) any changes in the patient or any of their concerns. You would also make sure the patient has everything that they need and that everything in their room is clean and free from hazardous conditions. There is the use of a call button which will light up at your station and you will have to go to that patents' room to assist them. You will be expected to report things to and keep your manager well informed about the patient.
On the other hand, being a Certified Medical Assistant is quite different and less physically and mentally hectic. For this position, you would be scheduling patient appointments, updating patients' medical records and medical histories, doing patient billing, collection, and bookkeeping, medical coding and insurance registration. So this is a much cleaner, less hectic job of the two and you would most likely be working in a doctors' office, an outpatient clinic, urgent care centers, specialty clinics like dermatology or orthopedic, or in a group medical practice office and you do not need to be certified as a Medical Assistant in the State of California, but if you do become certified, it may provide better career opportunities for you.
Now that I have illustrated somewhat the differences between the two careers, you can perhaps identify which one you would like. I do hope that this is helpful and I wish you all the best !
You ask an interesting question but far be it from me to say which career is better than any other career. No, you cannot be an Ultrasound Technician if you are a Certified Medical Assistant or a Certified Nurse's Aid. Those are two very different careers and you would have to take a specialized path to become an Ultrasound Technician.
If you want to determine which you'd like better, CMA or CNA, you'll need to explore both careers and pick the one that suits you best and the one that you like. If you have these fields of work explained to you, it may make it easier for you to make a personal choice about it.
Let's start with the career as a Nurse's Aid. I will base my information on personal extensive observation of many nurse's aids in action. I do not live in your state, so keep in mind that the guidelines, job duties and protocol for this position varies from state to state and depends on where exactly you will work. You most likely would work in a Hospital or a Nursing Home and Rehabilitation Center. That being said, the work is quite hectic. You would be doing direct patient care which includes bathing, dressing, grooming, transferring and repositioning of a patient, feeding and recording vital signs. You will need a neutral or high tolerance to bodily fluids because you will assist with changing and cleaning incontinence patients. There are a lot of job duties, so I continue. You would be responsible for reporting and recording (through charting) any changes in the patient or any of their concerns. You would also make sure the patient has everything that they need and that everything in their room is clean and free from hazardous conditions. There is the use of a call button which will light up at your station and you will have to go to that patents' room to assist them. You will be expected to report things to and keep your manager well informed about the patient.
On the other hand, being a Certified Medical Assistant is quite different and less physically and mentally hectic. For this position, you would be scheduling patient appointments, updating patients' medical records and medical histories, doing patient billing, collection, and bookkeeping, medical coding and insurance registration. So this is a much cleaner, less hectic job of the two and you would most likely be working in a doctors' office, an outpatient clinic, urgent care centers, specialty clinics like dermatology or orthopedic, or in a group medical practice office and you do not need to be certified as a Medical Assistant in the State of California, but if you do become certified, it may provide better career opportunities for you.
Now that I have illustrated somewhat the differences between the two careers, you can perhaps identify which one you would like. I do hope that this is helpful and I wish you all the best !
Updated
Sylvia’s Answer
Hi Jordan,
Your query seems a bit unclear. Are you referring to Certified Medication Aides or Certified Medical Assistants? I'll assume you're asking about Certified Medication Aides as they are more similar to CNAs.
Deciding between a CNA or Certified Medication Aide role depends largely on your work environment and patient load.
In a nursing home, a CNA might be responsible for 6 to 12 patients. This involves tasks like helping them dress, use the bathroom, eat, and answering their call lights. While there might be some downtime in a nursing home, in a hospital, you could be attending to up to 15 patients per 12-hour shift with no downtime. Assisted living facilities might offer more downtime, while CNAs in group homes might even sleep during night shifts. So, the nature of your job as a CNA can vary greatly depending on where you work.
Certified Medication Aides (CMAs) might have a different experience. While some states permit CMAs in nursing homes, others don't. If you're a CMA in a nursing home, your workload might be comparable to that of a nurse. Keep in mind, nurses generally have more responsibilities than CNAs. Some states require only basic training for CMAs. While hospitals don't typically hire CMAs, they do hire CNAs, which can be beneficial if you're considering further medical training. CMAs in nursing homes might spend 4 to 8 hours dispensing medication without a break, while CNAs might have more downtime.
My recommendation is to pursue both CNA and CMA certifications, which can be achieved within 3 months. Once you're hired, gauge the patient load for CMAs and CNAs at your institution and choose accordingly. Sometimes, you might be able to do both. Training for a Medical Assistant (MA) might take longer, possibly up to a year.
If you were asking about Medical Assistants, they are a different category altogether. MAs work in doctors' offices and don't need to be licensed or certified by the state. They could learn on the job, unlike CNAs and CMAs who must be registered. MAs work under a physician's license and their duties depend on the physician's needs. However, most physicians prefer hiring trained CMAs. Remember, the scope of practice for these professions varies by state.
Consider your long-term career goals when deciding between CNA, CMA, and MA roles.
Your query seems a bit unclear. Are you referring to Certified Medication Aides or Certified Medical Assistants? I'll assume you're asking about Certified Medication Aides as they are more similar to CNAs.
Deciding between a CNA or Certified Medication Aide role depends largely on your work environment and patient load.
In a nursing home, a CNA might be responsible for 6 to 12 patients. This involves tasks like helping them dress, use the bathroom, eat, and answering their call lights. While there might be some downtime in a nursing home, in a hospital, you could be attending to up to 15 patients per 12-hour shift with no downtime. Assisted living facilities might offer more downtime, while CNAs in group homes might even sleep during night shifts. So, the nature of your job as a CNA can vary greatly depending on where you work.
Certified Medication Aides (CMAs) might have a different experience. While some states permit CMAs in nursing homes, others don't. If you're a CMA in a nursing home, your workload might be comparable to that of a nurse. Keep in mind, nurses generally have more responsibilities than CNAs. Some states require only basic training for CMAs. While hospitals don't typically hire CMAs, they do hire CNAs, which can be beneficial if you're considering further medical training. CMAs in nursing homes might spend 4 to 8 hours dispensing medication without a break, while CNAs might have more downtime.
My recommendation is to pursue both CNA and CMA certifications, which can be achieved within 3 months. Once you're hired, gauge the patient load for CMAs and CNAs at your institution and choose accordingly. Sometimes, you might be able to do both. Training for a Medical Assistant (MA) might take longer, possibly up to a year.
If you were asking about Medical Assistants, they are a different category altogether. MAs work in doctors' offices and don't need to be licensed or certified by the state. They could learn on the job, unlike CNAs and CMAs who must be registered. MAs work under a physician's license and their duties depend on the physician's needs. However, most physicians prefer hiring trained CMAs. Remember, the scope of practice for these professions varies by state.
Consider your long-term career goals when deciding between CNA, CMA, and MA roles.
James Constantine Frangos
Consultant Dietitian & Software Developer since 1972 => Nutrition Education => Health & Longevity => Self-Actualization.
6193
Answers
Updated
James Constantine’s Answer
Hello Jordan!
When comparing Certified Medical Assistants (CMA) and Certified Nursing Assistants (CNA), it is essential to understand the roles, responsibilities, and career paths associated with each profession.
Role and Responsibilities
CMA: A CMA typically works in outpatient settings such as clinics and physician’s offices. Their duties include administrative tasks like scheduling appointments, managing patient records, billing, as well as clinical tasks such as taking vital signs, assisting with examinations, administering medications, and performing basic lab tests.
CNA: A CNA primarily provides direct patient care in settings like nursing homes, hospitals, or long-term care facilities. Their responsibilities focus on assisting patients with daily activities such as bathing, dressing, eating, and mobility. They also monitor patients’ conditions by checking vital signs and reporting any changes to nursing staff.
Education and Certification
CMA: To become a CMA, one typically needs to complete a postsecondary education program in medical assisting that usually lasts about one year. After completing the program, candidates must pass the certification exam administered by organizations such as the American Association of Medical Assistants (AAMA).
CNA: Becoming a CNA generally requires completing a state-approved training program that can last from a few weeks to several months. After training, candidates must pass a competency exam to obtain certification.
Career Opportunities and Advancement
CMA: CMAs often have more opportunities for advancement due to their broader skill set that includes both administrative and clinical tasks. They may advance into roles such as office manager or specialized medical assistant positions.
CNA: While CNAs can advance in their careers by pursuing further education to become Licensed Practical Nurses (LPNs) or Registered Nurses (RNs), their initial role is more limited compared to CMAs.
Job Outlook and Salary
According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), both professions are expected to grow; however, CMAs may have slightly higher earning potential due to their expanded skill set.
In summary, whether CMA is “better” than CNA depends on individual career goals and interests. If one prefers a role that combines administrative duties with patient care in an outpatient setting, then pursuing CMA might be more suitable. Conversely, if someone is interested in providing direct patient care primarily in long-term care or hospital settings without extensive administrative responsibilities, then becoming a CNA could be the better choice.
Ultrasound Tech Career Path
Regarding the second part of your question about becoming an ultrasound technician:
Educational Requirements
To become an ultrasound technician (also known as a diagnostic medical sonographer), individuals typically need an associate degree or bachelor’s degree in diagnostic medical sonography or a related field.
Certification
Most employers prefer candidates who are certified by recognized organizations such as the American Registry for Diagnostic Medical Sonography (ARDMS). Certification usually requires passing exams that demonstrate proficiency in various areas of ultrasound technology.
Relation to CMA/CNA Roles
While CMAs and CNAs do not directly lead to careers as ultrasound technicians due to differing educational requirements and scopes of practice, individuals can transition into this field by pursuing additional education specifically focused on sonography after obtaining their initial certifications.
In conclusion, while it is not typical for someone who is only trained as a CMA or CNA to work directly as an ultrasound tech without further education and training specific to sonography, it is certainly possible for those interested in advancing their careers through additional schooling.
Top 3 Authoritative Sources Used
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS): Provides comprehensive data on job outlooks and salary information for various healthcare professions.
American Association of Medical Assistants (AAMA): Offers resources regarding certification requirements for CMAs.
American Registry for Diagnostic Medical Sonography (ARDMS): Details certification processes for ultrasound technicians along with educational pathways required for entry into the field.
God Bless!
JC.
When comparing Certified Medical Assistants (CMA) and Certified Nursing Assistants (CNA), it is essential to understand the roles, responsibilities, and career paths associated with each profession.
Role and Responsibilities
CMA: A CMA typically works in outpatient settings such as clinics and physician’s offices. Their duties include administrative tasks like scheduling appointments, managing patient records, billing, as well as clinical tasks such as taking vital signs, assisting with examinations, administering medications, and performing basic lab tests.
CNA: A CNA primarily provides direct patient care in settings like nursing homes, hospitals, or long-term care facilities. Their responsibilities focus on assisting patients with daily activities such as bathing, dressing, eating, and mobility. They also monitor patients’ conditions by checking vital signs and reporting any changes to nursing staff.
Education and Certification
CMA: To become a CMA, one typically needs to complete a postsecondary education program in medical assisting that usually lasts about one year. After completing the program, candidates must pass the certification exam administered by organizations such as the American Association of Medical Assistants (AAMA).
CNA: Becoming a CNA generally requires completing a state-approved training program that can last from a few weeks to several months. After training, candidates must pass a competency exam to obtain certification.
Career Opportunities and Advancement
CMA: CMAs often have more opportunities for advancement due to their broader skill set that includes both administrative and clinical tasks. They may advance into roles such as office manager or specialized medical assistant positions.
CNA: While CNAs can advance in their careers by pursuing further education to become Licensed Practical Nurses (LPNs) or Registered Nurses (RNs), their initial role is more limited compared to CMAs.
Job Outlook and Salary
According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), both professions are expected to grow; however, CMAs may have slightly higher earning potential due to their expanded skill set.
In summary, whether CMA is “better” than CNA depends on individual career goals and interests. If one prefers a role that combines administrative duties with patient care in an outpatient setting, then pursuing CMA might be more suitable. Conversely, if someone is interested in providing direct patient care primarily in long-term care or hospital settings without extensive administrative responsibilities, then becoming a CNA could be the better choice.
Ultrasound Tech Career Path
Regarding the second part of your question about becoming an ultrasound technician:
Educational Requirements
To become an ultrasound technician (also known as a diagnostic medical sonographer), individuals typically need an associate degree or bachelor’s degree in diagnostic medical sonography or a related field.
Certification
Most employers prefer candidates who are certified by recognized organizations such as the American Registry for Diagnostic Medical Sonography (ARDMS). Certification usually requires passing exams that demonstrate proficiency in various areas of ultrasound technology.
Relation to CMA/CNA Roles
While CMAs and CNAs do not directly lead to careers as ultrasound technicians due to differing educational requirements and scopes of practice, individuals can transition into this field by pursuing additional education specifically focused on sonography after obtaining their initial certifications.
In conclusion, while it is not typical for someone who is only trained as a CMA or CNA to work directly as an ultrasound tech without further education and training specific to sonography, it is certainly possible for those interested in advancing their careers through additional schooling.
Top 3 Authoritative Sources Used
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS): Provides comprehensive data on job outlooks and salary information for various healthcare professions.
American Association of Medical Assistants (AAMA): Offers resources regarding certification requirements for CMAs.
American Registry for Diagnostic Medical Sonography (ARDMS): Details certification processes for ultrasound technicians along with educational pathways required for entry into the field.
God Bless!
JC.