4 answers
6
Asked 749 views

Is it better to have a less personal recommendation from someone with high authority, or a more personal recommendation from someone with a lower position?

#recommendations #applications #job-search #college-applications #college-admissions

job-search college-admissions college-applications applications recommendations
Answer This

+25 Karma if successful
From: You
To: Friend
Subject: Career question for you
6

4 answers

1
Updated
Share a link to this answer
Share a link to this answer

Aastha’s Answer

Hi! I would say a less personal from someone from high authority if you have to choose. If they can speak to your professional capabilities or their knowledge of you, that may be more helpful. If you can I would highly suggest having both, good luck!
1
1
Updated
Share a link to this answer
Share a link to this answer

Courtney’s Answer

It's actually a good idea to have both. But if you only secure one, it's better to secure the professional recommendation over the personal recommendation. My letters of recommendation included 1 from a teacher, one from my boss at my internship/job/volunteer work; and one from a family friend.
1
0
Updated
Share a link to this answer
Share a link to this answer

Nicole’s Answer

Hi Jasmine O. I see that you posted this question a little while ago so I hope my answer to you (or others who may read this response) is still helpful.

I agree that both can be helpful. Where possible, though, give yourself some time to build a relationship with someone you might consider "less personal" and that is of "high authority". This person of "high authority"...maybe reach out to them to ask for a little time. Maybe you can attend a (virtual) talk that they are giving.

In general, a "personal" recommendation or letters of recommendation are so much more impactful both in the ask and in the letter provided, when you, in fact, have a good, authentic relationship. It is impactful in the ask because often times the person who you ask for the recommendation is honored that you chose them. It is impactful in the letter provided because you get to hear from others how highly they think of you and/or how much they recommend you for a position or task.

I hope you find this response helpful.

Best of luck!
0
0
Updated
Share a link to this answer
Share a link to this answer

Judy’s Answer

Teachers and people you may have worked for are good recommendations. Also school counselors and leaders of any clubs you belong to. One or two personal references are also ok in addition to that.
0